10/24/2026
Three of these Long Island town stories are true. One is a myth.
1️⃣ Shelter Island was bought for 1,600 lbs of sugar
2️⃣ Orient used to be called Oyster Ponds
3️⃣ Smithtown was won by riding a bull
4️⃣ Port Jefferson was once called Drowned Meadow
Think you know your Long Island history? Comment 1, 2, 3 or 4 below 👇