02/08/2023
In a recent decision, the High Court has held that where the Commissioner has deemed an objection as invalidly lodged and communicated this to the taxpayer as required by law, the Commissioner is still statutory bound to issue an objection decision within 60 days failure to which the invalid objection is deemed allowed by dint of section 51(11) of the Tax Procedures Act (TPA).
In the said case, the Commissioner had requested the Taxpayer to validate their objection by availing relevant documents, which the taxpayer failed to do. The Commissioner issued its decision confirming its assessment 64 days after the Taxpayer had lodged its objection. Aggrieved by the Commissioner's decision, the Taxpayer appealed to the Tax Appeals Tribunal (Triunal) which dismissed the appeal finding the Commissioner's delay of 4 days as not inordinate and curable under Article 159 of the Constitution which frowns upon procedural technicalities. On appeal, the High Court faulted the Tribunal's decision and allowed the Taxpayer's appeal finding, inter alia, as follows:
1. The Tribunal erred in deeming an express statutory edict as a matter of procedural technicality. Article 159 of the Constitution could not oust express statutory provisions. The Tribunal failed to appreciate the difference between a procedural law (also called adjective law which is a law governing​ ​the machinery of the courts and the methods by which rights are enforced) and substantive law (which is a statutory law which deals with the legal relationship between people or the people and the state);
2. Once it was established that the objection decision had been issued late, the issue of validity of the objection became immaterial and the Tribunal fell into grave error in entertaining the same; and,
3. Objection decisions must be issued within 60 days on all objections, whether valid or invalid.
This decision is relevant for many taxpayers who might have been called upon to validate their objection notices by providing relevant/additional information (which in some instances is unspecified and if specified, generally outrageous). Where the Commissioner fails to issue an objection decision within 60 days, the objection notices will stand allowed by law, whether validated or not.