08/27/2024
๐๐ก๐๐ง ๐๐ฌ ๐๐ก๐ ๐๐๐๐ค๐๐จ๐จ๐ซ ๐๐จ๐ญ๐ก ๐๐ฏ๐๐ง ๐๐จ๐ซ๐ญ๐ก ๐๐จ๐ข๐ง๐ ?
Before reviewing the rules and strategies for efficiently and effectively using the backdoor Roth strategy, let us first address the concern raised by many advisors, clients, and tax preparers, which is some variation of, "This sounds like a lot of work for $7,000 or $8,000"
Going around to the back door makes sense when you canโt get in through the front. Making backdoor Roth contributions is an extension of the broader decision that going with a Roth makes sense for a particular taxpayer. For taxpayers who are concerned they will be in a higher tax bracket in the future, either because their income increases or because tax laws change, backdoor Roth contributions can be a great tool for filling up their tax-free bucket. We should first explore contributory Roth options through employer sponsored retirement plans (which donโt have the income limits that Roth IRAs do) and verify the taxpayer canโt make direct Roth IRA contributions before beginning backdoor Roth contributions.
To understand the value of the backdoor Roth strategy of 'just' $7,000 annually, backdoor Roth contributions of $7,000 in each of the next 20 years growing at 10% annually could produce a tax-free bucket of some $400,000(double, if married.) Which, in round numbers, would save you some $50,000 in taxes.
The Backdoor Roth Strategy Sounds Great, But What Exactly Is It?
It's important to first acknowledge that the backdoor Roth IRA contribution is not officially a 'thing', at least not to the IRS, but rather a tax loophole that the IRS and Congress know about but have chosen not to close (thankfully, the IRS has acknowledged that taxpayers are using this strategy and has not made any focused effort to prevent or crack down on it).
More specifically, the backdoor Roth IRA strategy consists of a 2-step process involving 1) a contribution made to a traditional IRA, followed by 2) conversion into a Roth IRA. This process is designed to get annual contributions into a Roth IRA for taxpayers whose income levels surpass the Roth IRA contribution phaseout range, precluding them from making these contributions. For 2024, the income phaseout for a taxpayer (Married Filing Jointly) making contributions to a Roth IRA ranges from $230k to $240k of Modified AGI (reported on Form 1040 Line 11, with some adjustments)
What is Co-Mingling?
Unfortunately, things get complicated quickly if taxpayers have existing IRA dollars (in any account) and/or if they plan to rollover funds from a qualified account at any point during the year. This is because of the IRA Aggregation Rule which states the value of all IRA accounts will be aggregated together for the purpose of any tax calculations.
Example: Bob, did a $6,500 backdoor Roth. But has $100,000 of pre-tax money in another IRA.
Because of the $100,000 pre-tax and $6,500 after-tax balances, the combined total account value reported on Line 6 of Form 8606 would be $100,000 + $6,500 = $106,500, which means that every future distribution would be approximately $100,000 ยธ $106,500 = 93.9% taxable and $6,500 ยธ $106,500 = 6.1% tax-free.
So instead of Bob's $6,500 being converted wholly tax free as he originally thought would be the case, what actually ended out happening was that only $6,500 ยด 6.1% = $397 was tax free, and the remaining $6,500 โ $397 = $6,103 was taxable!
Anything Else I Should Know About Backdoor Roth Conversions?
Anytime we are talking about IRAs, Roths, contributions, and/or conversions, we need to revisit both the 5-year rule that applies to Roth conversions (which serves to determine whether the principal of amounts converted to Roth can be considered penalty-free), and the 5-year rule that applies to Roth contributions (which serves to determine whether a withdrawal of growth from a Roth IRA would be considered a tax-free 'qualified' distribution, and for which separate rules exist for Roth accounts under employer retirement plans).
Any distributions taken from a qualified account are characterized in the following order: first from Contributions, then from Conversions, and lastly from Growth.
The 1st 5-year Rule (for Roth conversion principle) says that account owners under age 59.5 must wait 5 years before they can withdraw the principal of a prior Roth conversion without penalty (ignoring any other qualifying event). Once the client reaches age 59.5, this 5-year rule is no longer an issue.
The 2nd 5-year rule (for Roth growth of any type) says that any Growth on a Roth (from contributions or converted amounts) cannot be withdrawn without penalty until they have had any Roth account open for at least 5 years (and they must be over age 59 ยฝ, or deceased or disabled, or using the money under the first-time homebuyer exception).
If this all sounds complicated and labor-intensive, take a step back to remind yourself that strategies like these can be beneficial and well worth the time and effort they require to implement; taking the time to understand them can result in numerous tax-free dollars.
Bull Financial has vast experience with Roth IRA planning. Everyoneโs unique situation creates its own path of action to create their most tax-efficient scenario. Use the link below to schedule a quick 15 minute phone call or Zoom to see if Roth planning makes since and could benefit your financial future.
Barry Barnette
Bull Financial
https://bull.financial/