06/29/2025
If you're a small business owner, you've probably seen ads from companies that promise to save you thousands by converting your Schedule C business to an LLC taxed as an S corporation. Is it true?
Like most business tax related questions, the answer is "it depends." If your business is consistently profitable, then yes, possibly. The main savings comes from the fact that when you file on Schedule C (which is where most small businesses start), your entire income is subject to self-employment tax, also known as paying both employer and employee halves of F**A.
As the employee of your S corporation, you still pay both halves of F**A on your salary. But your net income from the business is only subject to normal income tax. And if you need money beyond your salary to cover personal expenses, you can take distributions that in most cases aren't subject to additional tax.
Let's say your Schedule C business is consistently making $80,000 a year. That means you're paying $12,240 (15.3% of $80,000) in F**A in addition to the income taxes on that $80,000. Change to an S corporation and pay yourself a $40,000 salary, and now you're paying $6,120 in F**A. So yes, in the right situation you can in fact save thousands. There are additional expenses, fees, and paperwork requirements to consider, but for the right person and the right business, S corporation taxation can be a good idea.
If you read the previous paragraph and wondered if you can pay yourself $0 salary to avoid F**A completely...sorry, that won't work. The IRS requires your salary to be "reasonable." But it was a good idea.